Microsoft Word - Candidates for 2017 ERP of the Year
Manuscript Title, Submitter and Reviewers
ERP Decisions / Consensus
AOAC Method #
Title: Leaner and Greener Analysis of Cannabinoids Author(s): E Mudge, SJ Murch, PN Brown ‐Submitted by: Elizabeth Mudge, BCIT ‐Primary Reviewer: Holly Johnson, AHPA ‐Secondary Reviewers: Christian Sweeney, Cannibistry
Dissenter comments: The method seems to fall short of SMPRs and is lacking sufficient data to support conclusions. Dissenter explained that this comment is primarily about the oil samples, and that the method is acceptable with regards to dry materials. Regardless, more data on oils would be preferred. The method author explained that oils were not commercially available when this study was done and they had to develop this oil in‐house. The ERP discussed this and agreed that this issue does not disqualify the method from meeting SMPR 2017.002, Quantitation of Cannabinoids in Dried Plant Materials. The scope will be clearly stated upon publication. MOTION to move this method to First Action Official Methods of Analysis Status (Johnson/Audino) 13 in favor, 0 opposed, 2 abstentions. The motion passed
CAN‐002
Action Items: AOAC Staff to prepare ERP report and distribute to method authors and ERP members. AOAC publications team will work with method authors on publishing the methods in eOMA. As per discussion, ERP will convene to review collaborative study protocol prior to studies being conducted if requested.
5
Made with FlippingBook - Online catalogs