Debating Society_Minute book_1938-45

•J

kTERS. DUBLIN

w

'(..I 3W:k/

+1.

SOLICITORS'

APPRENTICE!

D3BATITJG

S00IBTY

OF

IR3LA1TD

SBSSI01T

1938 - 39

.OFFIOBSS :-

AUDITOR

Mr. A- Forrest Eussey, B.A., L.I»3-

- Mr. B .

1- . O'Byrne

- Mr. B. J. lynch

HOTT.

TR3ASUR3R

-

Mr. P. J. ITutley

Mr. G. 1. dollins

_Mr. T.. G. Grotty,

Mi as 3 . MoMull en, 3 A .

Mr. P. I. Gib son, B.A. (ex-Auditor - ex-officio)

SOLICITORS'

APPRENTICES'

DEBATING

SOCI3TY

The closing meeting of the 54th Session of the Society was held on Monday, 30th May 1938, in the Solicitors' Buildings, Pour Courts, Dublin. The Auditor, Mr. P. I. Gib son, presided. The Minutes of the previous Meeting were read and signed with– out alteration. The Auditor read his report on the affairs of the Society during the Session. Mr. Maher proposed and Mr. Kelly seconded "that the Auditors' Report be adopted". The Report was, after some minor criti– cisms, declared carried. The Balance Sheet and a Supplementary Balance Sheet were read by the Hon. Treasurer. Mr. Lynch proposed' and Mr. Hussey seconded, "that the Balance Sheet be adopted". This Motion was carried by 14 votes to 5. Mr. Sheedy proposed that the House go into committee "to consider the Balance Sheet". This was postponed till later. The Auditor declared the awards of prizes for the Session 1937- 38 to be as followS;-

ORATORY

Incorporated Law Society Gold Medal and Society's Certificate - - Mr. P.L. Gibson, B.A- Society's Silver Medal and Certificate - Mr. B.P. O'Byrne- Society's Special Certificate - - Mr. G. L. Collins

L3GAL

D3BAT3 ' President's Gold Medal and Society's Certificate Society' s Silver Medal and Certificate

-

-

Mr. B. P. O'Byrne

-

-

Mr. 0. S. Kelly Mr. Collins and Mr. Kelly received equal marks in the Competition for the Silver Medal in Legal Debate.

Mr. Kelly

finally winning on the toss of a coin.

I lit ROMP TU

Vice-President's Gold Medal and Society's Certificate - - Vice-President's Silver Medal and Society's Certificate - -

Mr. P.L. Gibson, B.A.

Mr. M.

J. O'Higgins

IRISH

Society's Silver Medal and Certificate

-

-

-

Miss M. Doorly''

Y3AR SPSBGHBS Socsisty' s Silver Medal and Certificate . -r -

-

-

Mr. B. P. O'Byrne

COMPOSITION

Incorporated Law Society' s Gold Medal and Society's Certificate -

Mr. B. P. O'Byrne

A list of those who had received aril' returned Ballot papers was read by the Hon. Corr. Sec. The result of the election of Officers and Committee for the Session 1938-39 was declared as f ollows:-

AUDITOR

..

••

•• .. •• ••

•• .. . - ••

•• Mr. A-F.Hussey, B.A., L.L.B.,

HON..._HBJCORD_S3CR3TARJ

. . Mr. B-P. O'Byrne • • Mr . B . J. Lynch .. Mr. p.J. Nutley

HON.._GORR.__ S3CRBTARY

§PNj.__TRBASUR3H_

••

COMMITTS3:-

Mr. G. L. Collins'

'

'

Mr. T. G. Crotty jg->^. Miss 3. McMullen, B.A. Mr. 1-. L. Gib son B.A-, (Ex-Auditor - ex-officio)

The new Auditor & Committee then entered into office, Mr. Hussey, the incoming Auditor congratulated the outgoing Auditor £ Committee on a very successful year of office. Mr. Gib son (ex-Auditor) welcomed the new Auditor & Committee and wished them complete success- The House, with acclamation, endorsed these sentiments- Mr. V7allace proposed and Mr.Kelly seconded a motion of congratulation to Mr. Crotty on his being elected Auditor of the Law Society in U.C-D- This motion was passed unanimously. The House then went into Committee to consider the .Balance Sheet. Mr. Sheedy proposed, Fir. O'Figgins seconded "That last years Balance Sheet, being in two parts, shall be read as one consecu tive document, and shall include copy signatures of the Auditor & .. Scrutineers already appended thereto." After a long discussion the Motion was lost by 8 votes to 5. House then went out of Committee, & thjfcAuditor closed the «v meeting. ^Tl/l/^^ ———7

41** .H'frtflirfab K-ij&o

^ &e (Ztt+^y'&.sZeirJ^Jt

0titevu 4*4>f' * fc,

U*4

^^J

Jtr* Ae^i^t

'. /c*s£***>* £p1ic^.

Kc.

f^p^J & d*&-ai tyLfa^t*,

i&ikuj^a^ Z^J^GJ. a-^-'

,£^_

Tew '/fXQTiv/V

-t

t9€&9ULd

ue

ML -fai

j $-

/

/

. V'UpyvJ. /%_. y

JfcU-ffelRB

C&td£ /6*c&e)

c*~

tf) X C^r. ^Jf • 4?-

,

C/ofctifaM.

7

V.

-f

-&*

Si t 4 h

VAJL

. - fa^Jlfcr

GwG.wnlATiou.

4r1Z»^4 &-, Jo* ™*tJJLL^. -f~*JL_ CJt^r+JXZ, «****-. ,r, 7^7.n, vT ^cr^

O £-0- ii- r* —*——

<^w~J: (fet fcr*

$.££*&y,k l^rf^u^^J-^

AKi

a

Icy

at'

&£, h

TVw/*/,

•£f*V.

>

/„.

c^w d

rvLM . t fa. "0 '&G^ *«t .

ofl AOL

M<_ j& ^6^v ,' fyUvm. b'/ttcft^* -*K&t M&tierh 4rtL»

A *'

Z^

V f &*&*+*+-*$ /&p>*e. 4***t&*«> *?*i9-*3 4L 'frUsv+y.

^JAJ&ACA- 1) d'Mf^Gf^,

'XZ^&O h> OL*T»^_ __V ^^O ^^-.^ ^

W*. d'fa*^

- 8 -0

fa

&v

Jwfl-3b/«

a*

.

<%L

*

(/I

/•

^ #•

. r- ^^t: ^ f. UcM^ 7^ #«3&L 7 / "~7

oJrOHA

»>l

La

d)

o'

'C ft

^Utt^fHo ~ ^^ &t>

\t &*

L*^ ^$>e*u>-

> C^t^JL-t)

jZT^p-^*-^ <**>*&.

I

^

~

T

N

_

*__

^^x? ^^4f

£r

!*fc*Jl

Cuy leof-

,

bo

y

Ji /M*fi

wv

4*"^-

6F-

f.

An*

wr

*0<9*j^

^t

A

_

5

tf-

XT-

fa

4

//

V

/A&A~

£"•

Y<

Cy

<*-«

f-

JRJL

"ivtox^vv.

7 t

3At (.

J\

A

f^'\

'

H-i

JL

^ it r-J-r 4 :! F J L ii w C *

"**>

rp

_1

g,

0

^o———Lrffc*

7)

/4 j

-Wor*--J 6.

^r. fa£&

f • — ' V JP 4r«Tc-^t) £M-O kt*Cif~ S&L

/

]*Jf^-

9

*'1U-

fa

j it,

fe«07F.

(feoJjT^

.8&Mi , %* v

"i

Q

"

v. 2). '*<-

/g.?r

I

J «

X<

(tiv pub**. a*~f

?;

QO&r*.

1**^ ^ jut) tftpiutj -wfi: s&ei+e^ O£&ZL£*^S

ffii

&

Jk &4p-*

9HHtn&;

l<\it

4to*v. 6-J. -facts t T- WfoJfab t fl

7

»

4*J

) f".

^4

/ Zfo^ V J

Fcrr.

At

- \

/

fc f ' P • .

4 xX

tZ, Ot k

/We

A/'

Cf fa

I

^/

1

4*

l

I

jg^^tft-JttJ.

^•V r^^l rf 30

•+m*> k£j

'/

fytr*s.f

Vo4t

/z£

at- fa

?f|

fa

4 -

/ktffot .

£Kt, mt**,

ff

-i £-3-

. (JJ&« **

/

"

£'0'^ fa *

-fc

/Q, ~7 s

74

- DJL^.

*«*£»

i

/ >>

^—

tfcp oj fc.

^e^jL

^x

Cx

/fa.

*X-

i i

V

/ S

"tc5&

'^o-Kfex-o tfy**

flor

A

-^fc/-. /K^.

** fO /( • i-

&ej- s&d4>4.

£4e \

. tf*^, *\ *

'

V

M

s**-

" /cii

~

a/fe&te jvr&il&'Hfct, J*r A****fcr*& tf 0a*t

bfi+e.

0

. -.f*^ P J.

ltd

iiuut- *v AW^Jt ^ \$'^lpJ^f i&<*~& fty^&M &«*^6z el* Kc£fo4iQ)J^

4*

fitf l&

fifr

6/0

.

,

&

7W4

!)0 frLu»j2^

i-/-&~Mj , tyajjA£>'A4tX*%, .

6 &*M+

s***at46*t£

^Ct^t/

x^2t-

^o

^^^^cJ^ ^ A faJLbr * &u~v&» ^^i' ^ S ^fei/. ^^ //fe &+Ml *4t*refct*' J Ifa ^f)

t-4sn-~-r£>

i

-

/ * IT

" >Z?77

^-z^

"/ ' TV "

,£^77'

7 -^ jCr-r-rr-^,

XT ^7°^

^ /*

b /'"Tyf^

*-y&s£>

ATO ^zn^o^f^

iji iic^ 0T»-)f

-n-or& ^ayyea^ -rw?

^/

V

' I/ '

JU-

t

"

-^y fr**

•ff

<*?

' n^L,

/

—w-yr

/

9pf ^°^ -f^-t-p.

^wy-r>7 r~**>j

ffy/

9-*~*iO*

&™-ja **jrfr£

JG^-~-rtKr-rrr

fc^eV<^/w*JVA_v

->-w~»_~C»

Q I JL J ?

.

w-»—»^»

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICE DEBATING SOCIETY OF IRELAND

SESSION

3L938 - 39.

OFFICERS :-

AUDITOR

-

-

-

-

Mr. M. J. Egsn B.A.

- Mr. P. J. fiutley

-

1Ir • L • ^ • Bo^d

HON.

TEEAEUEE

'

1*. L. M. 'Lev: ling-

COMMITTEE

:-

'

... .-SBES-

-

-.

;'V^"

Miss L. Pagan B.A.

•''-

i,r

Miss A. Hyland B.A.

Mr. T. Reilly

Mr. A Forroat Huaaey B.A. LL.b.

(Ex AvidAtor - Ex Officio

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICES' DEBATING SOCIETY.

The closing Meeting of the 55th Session of the Society was held on the 5th May,1939 in the Solicitors' Buildings,Pour Courts, Dublin. Mr. A.Forrest Hussey,LL.B. presided. The Minutes of the previous Meeting were read and signed without alteration.

The Auditor read his report on the affairs of the Society

during the Session.

Mr.B.J.Lynch proposed and Mr. Nutley seconded

that "the Auditors report be adopted". The report,after some minor

criticism was declared carried.

The Balance Sheet was read by the

Hon f Treasurer,Mr.P.J.Nutley. Mr.Kelly proposed and Mr.Lynch seconded

"that the balance sheet be adopted". The Motion was carried without

opposition.

The Auditor then declared the awards of prizes for the

Session 1938-'39 to be as follows:-

ORATORY ;

Society Silver Medal and Certificate.

................... Mr.P.J.Nutley.

Legal Deoate

: Society's Silver Medal...................Mr.A.Porrest Hussfey.

Impromptu Debate;

Society's Silver Medal ..................Mr.A.Porrest Hussey. Special Certificate ..................Mr.M.J.O'Higgins.

Irish Debate;

Society's Silver Medal ..................Miss s. Doorly. and Certificate.

First Year Speeches.

Society'3 Silver Medal and Certificate

................. Mr. P. P. 0« Sullivan.

'

""

A List of those who had received and returned Ballot papers was read

The result of the election of Officers and Committee ,

by Hon.Corr.Sec.

for the Session 1939-40. was declared as follows.

"

................................... Mr. M.J.Egan,B. A.

Auditor

Hon. Record Sec. ................................... Mr.P.J.Nutley. Hon.Corr.Sec. ................................... Mr.L.D.Boyd. Hon. Treasurer ................................... Mr .D.M. Bowling. - Commit tee";- i Miss L. Pagan,B. A. JUi Miss A.Hyland,B.A. Mr.T.O'Reilly. . Mr.A.Porrest Hussey,B.A.,LL.B. (Ex Auditor Ex Officio). The new Auditor and Committee then entered into office. Mr.Egan, the in- coming Auditor congratulated the out -going Auditor and Committee on a very successful year of office. Mr.Hussey(Ex Auditor) welcomed the new Auditor and Committee and wished them complete success. Mr.Higgins proposed and Mr. Grotty seconded the following Motion "That it is the considered opinion of this Society that for / the benifit of Apprentices who sincerely desire to obtain a satisfact- ory knowledge of Law and Practice during their term of service, the legal Practitioners' Qualification (Ireland) Act 1939 should be repeal- j ed . An amendment to this motion was proposed by Miss Betty Kelly j which read "that; the standard of the preliminary Irish examination be raised and that the second Irish examination be eliminated, except for those who afterwards wished to practise within the Gaeltacth to whom a Special certificate be awarded". After a long discussion the i motion was carried by 12 votes to 2. in accordance with Rule 71 of the Rules and Seeding Orde/Sj of the Society the Meeting terminated at eleven o'cloj

/*«.

/ed tilth

-ft ,W

trf

n

H 4u

Mftfn 7

*j k* JO«**Y L/xfivd. A A -f^eS y^i •fa&tt *&r **&££• ***"t (fa

•* d

•!,+•*•

M

' *

a- ti/

"9-1

/uf&* i^Ltkfn A&*. Q ft* \vU4&? 0P.

(U*L ZuMJUtWL *i*rt- fetHJ ^> **#*£<.

/?/$$& thntuJ: V foi

'

*

,

,

,

if

Jy^totvrf ^/^4-

j /^/^W-^^TT/" -KAA-4 *•' * / A/7 '- ttysyUd, ^ifuM, ^ckfaMwtf J**J*£A&1 / * . , SI f\ A '^WA^ uktitl

(j ^w z '^oMf /iMeirtJiL'A. id. ff.

n

A

n.

ft

tkd- $os ^£~

iUnlfa *t /&

/] >iht ,

if- /jviw.u4>

fat ML

Zi«f/&-ircafy J^AjJi M#4

A

i I *i

f1

i

\n ^

J&

J& fa<%dr~£iq&te Oe&A

/ fl &Hs sfcU t£~ JjLi*u$M~ '• Ml /C

I

l&oi

,/ /• ,d ' At/lftA Wbo J&{

Uf A / ,/Wrij^z>t ^

/\i*l fa ' J.

Jfc

/ / ^ /

/>.

/£«" A*&4* .

J&M^ /^/ x*4>

W foctl Jjfrffrti, . I .. /L

.

j~ / / »

-

/

C/

//~

/*/

/ / $*/ s

U&> /h+rf

/tec&Ji

/ #

-' L/

/rifff

?

''Sju'd /&/,

f / /A^i^^ Mert^kl ^4 , '/•/

!>^r(

\

M Jl It-

T

f)

'

(

I

^

$*

*

ts^f/rv H-^H

/o-t

>nf

*{••

Ml

/W&Mf M)&<4

4»l

fa

1+4.

$*%>

A^D

evL

*>/

^r

. C-

!>•.

/3. -* fl^, £• M /•/«

, u4 v .,/) (7

*/

,

]{• P. W

J.&

:^v /» AjU tfc PUMk ' D - r ^*^

AM

" ^ W"

^*

. dr&ne^L sU^

fou4

flb

/$% /w

atiifi

/ /

fj fc

fit

/VWurt -^te

Y^/ 0c0

*>&>

A

)& ffc-

Il0u^n(fa* LY kuLiu

^^ fi^r jy^afael Jbf itr flttb^U y^ Mdti^

L-

ftl 4% iftlffL /£» '

4A

/f ^

Te-

#/Ci£b- 9v\_£wi/(M-r-) .

Q.

^(

D-

n M^^^u^^^ jQatAt&.frz (A^A^vicA^ *- /<-

C (KH^ii""-(£&/*<&

//ri4*yt KP-O ^ fc~ fce

f

• / /

,/

/—— -' ^ S-/«r. TUo ^tffoft f- ttn?r> Y'.^-^-MY- ./fe^i? .^^/e faese

*+(

Ajt*jA. (\ fas M ^ JjL

fr —-

jr zat&Ji

^*

it /UC- /ho ChJi'l^c£»*. x

*-, /WtY ^M^JlfcJr

/ ^ P /-^^^ >5ff- \4Jt^*fy*tjL

4

>

4*

/C&+*

*J-

** .

M /^W A ^ j y X* ^i*xxd

JL

X^

r\

/

A

o ,

,

,

,

\\

A dctut^lLvJc /"• ••

tudttL

dtvodJe.

•hvMLe

. ^.

.

I

fftu~

Jtr

/v

^v^-Ur

J] jjL yksujiL I

Q

1 U&r.

/

.#*-

\

x3

l^i cLetfi***.* J3~* &* ^Jtf-7

tL Oiv~l$

u^rv-

L

^?

£E /\*fU4v^f Jl $,

*

e\

.to*

-

/L CLdtfK, ,x ^JJ^ ti /hw^v A 4^" /U^^fU^, jf. /

/ ^£j*. ^i^st^^ frcdJ^s

A^-^i-^J tfi£es\

-faefiiitJty

\tCJM« *0«^> lu/a /p*,

/WHJL&vij ji £fa

Aj**J(A.JL

.(L+*l

/3

«/?

ftSLsrfLS**-*

T' JL&t^i*£

~

fi^rfuu-ek I*/ fat* yltUfo y^fcc&*^ a* J W ts

or*

rn<)-"**v

ffnjt

<7At*K

+-

^"^

7 ^-y-/ '/UwU /**

^U-/ M*4

fff>cfi&^

/iMJitt^*-A

Inj u)a*>

'

'

.

/

, ft

//

/*

y

T\

* /"

/A.

y

f?

faM*

,

1 iMiM J&JL

ft?** #1)Ma.

.

OwA

/-/Wife?.

Cfonc*

> AOX^ ^=> /itc£u>j~J * fu/fcMe^ h fc L

* J) fit /lrou*L Jfc t^' lfr*i] /£. a

Jt- tfuko a*"l Mhu&r Prtbt i/J

J^ (^Ji- d Jkbu£k

/S> /Z^b -^/^noL

£' dfe ^^AflK Jfc' SVLLirJ /k

/I * /&<&£

( a^

'pi'1 kfaftlii y><** ^f J?tT-vs/dt*y ^1/^co & /u*J if X' JK$jfy /fa s)tn*(L J) fa l/trlv&M. U^i H cenM^^JUif (s It it Cfafa*. JbZ 0t«faJ[. Jfc CiuMtfV Jb <*> ^r/iA«x^)^t 0 . ~.t Jfc £M^£tf 8>^> ^T"^extMV3 a. iA«x /ut* a

*Z ~Zi

J^flv^ /^ h-UL

ff

r

/

I

J

'

U

n

M ^uW f >-^A

L $Q~La* fa*J* Wu*tt*sJots sf n &

fl&OA& O^sr^^JL^

(w Vu>-i>^ J ,y£-ffu-tk H^ ^i^a^i^J rfv s*°J~^Lly^ &4' J^K^h ID y^ A-ttA ' " " ' ~ • •' "

/jfaZ fat, &£

45^ ^S~2cT ^tn^T. fa •

JL

.

/

0 \

' i

(X

C_T ; ™

ila

X*

"7 Z*

tw

tftf

'.,*

^te' ^£>O

.

t,

•rv&tn

<7

.

j^ fa /^SieU'" Y-"

a/ ^

-/—•

/*o^

&L

A

tit

f^l

le $T

/Jr-~- &tllejdsev^ J^nf /

(7

*f

OVA

fl

/

/>

. _

, ^U 0k

/1^ /t^pJfc ^ *fa r/fj*

CisUsaA^eti. /U^jL .

J/HA iA

• 4;

/ ^

- LJV

V

~ t A~ 4W<**- $<^ M . H. y o u " V V ~ I— I

•% '1^*"^ fa o

/ -^ »yv ^ _j*ur*dv

y™pr>w •&'-<&> (

W^/'^ ^•v^r-p.

,.

^**

J

r

*

rft

^y r*

X "

fr

f Jw

f-b

tL

. $L

TC

u^o^j

U_v=*ja«o(>A^o . &

UL.

•CUAxo-Ji-O^

Cuv-O^

N-C-O^*-

0

i

-\

Q

~%4rV

K>rM'x£x-^^t.

'

l

AD ^J/

^D i~T

A

^xJ^VU^

/Yv>OLc»^cj

tb

TVVy\ .

e-K^xv^ .

<5T5

IkaxJ^la

_

AX*.

IcT

OXi

ft

^rvRj&A-

V\j ovxLoA

.

/•

. ™

^\

\A) <*-X/a-^- .

cy\A

cP

0

l/lt-X^l

s\\Jlsr>JlS\f> —--^- 0 ,. ,^-

^T. -

--v_C^3^

V

vi , O ^

vQj^jA-^r-*-^^

>ti_>

/Ks»--wA>^-a-

La

^-Jkoo^^vi.

^<^< ^/ ^

.<9LJ?/ / ^ fe2y^l6iSC&£. j

d

I \}

'

fl

ran PN

ne? vcren4Kxr>O

^

^ ) u- eJk^ ^ ->>\je->i—^*-VD

^yn£^i^

XUxr^^UxUxlA^

^x

^

£&&&*^t

s&T*4

^X

/Iv

=5^?

P~ t tA&h-CoU sh*~jA

1

Ow O

cxA/M

S-,

crv^

^ tL

Uo

^Jt^

.

\xJG^-Uv^

2S

*„ -

Trvv /-

^

\\^J^2^A

crl"

^Q,«lXlAJLX.c«-AX^

L*>VVtQivX>VvJ3(^V---/9

(jK

1—

f~t

'

rvt

L 0

1 —

JLj>~~JSkjL*^*-*

\A*

\pa^-...ci

ut.

x^-t

)——xAXJ"V\J

/^^^T^

'

J

.

• on

vT. £?

C«o-*^**^ C/b&J

L*~t

l^j

^UYV^<~-

4*A.<^.J

£>' GL^V*-^

(OV\ •

tr

__

-m.. O'Q^U^ x UJtU^, . $^. ^t>o^ v*&^~*i l*-~'

-4*-^^ TVK.1 A_Ji_ , -I'l IT- inn- I ?f

bj^i&K. ^ N l^-

-rn^j, n

^&5j> ^-** ~ jSLe^ J x. sy***~v&«, f^(^*j» .

^\^^^}

"TP

r\A-\

(r^vv^rTra^

—I \l

G— i

^J

x^-t^y\

^-^try-«oxY

•~^>Y^^^rff~{

"Yl

-^^yv^-vxc

/° ^

yy^H,.

--V--X3 "v^r^-/fV

LI

V^T ,7?

^ j , -v ^iJj

(<*rr^

^r^^^O-^t^

/y-^P v

t*-*r . \<\

>,

/LA-L/jyi—

V->C'U<-'\X'-O

Q^CCA-^ .

48.

_

'^n^^U^f^/ df l*v xlc/v^tt.

(fa $

^

T

;oj^

/T/n^-w^Jj-e/i-o

tfc /rvsv-txxuL.

k^-cszju_&i*d

OK

'M'

ov (A

?

cr^L^*^ rK ">^>M

'^eArv.OxUAA^

IfV/V

tt ~

|^XA^

Pcr'

j* c -

iti

•i

•••'£-

*'.'4»

£L——a*-

1L

L^

i2

^2e^—(

J6-c

O»--cJ-«xr

-v-^

.

Cl^Jr

JL»*Jt

i

v

'3

£f*<\.

"To JX^2^ ^ ^tY^l^f^

*yr\ «S| W-^y-e^l^v^^Vrcv

*T>^v^i~*4s ,.. .^] •*, -,1*,^.^

ft>

' ^s~YT>~~r~3/3Df

V

C_

_?"| myo+o *-**

90

°**

~O

~I> or-*y~rr^tsru4/

+4

r

a

o^2/j^ ^ftTs

t:ryy ^ //^y

~^ 2f&^~t**\s'

/^y&>

^j^

71

/^^vwr *rano

i

cU»-/>

cf JLi<3

t/^

Ciy

)b*a/z

£

>c-. e

Mtfcr

/ it, vn

«£<»*xn/ £/ ClA^^^^CJ^ &d

CK-

p

I—

I -

^W

k^IxvA*-^

i

0

0

C\XxV>^ftJV-M

VlLe^vJlLA^Oc.

mTY^

KJ2o^s_^ CTW

5 ttL K^vCA/t

cvt^W. rvC.c^

'U/vL'K.

Jyv_AJ>* Jwi,

C

<2*>W

tfc. <^~

/Jl/1 u &rvn-&^

LKX^JB cUuA

(^

'Wfi^»

AX-

r

v/v

I13°I

U it

£»VU_^o(

V)

,-JLrzi^Wv

-

cx/v

c^\suuL/3

,

Tru

vUfT"-4lJ(^

yH/» -

C\r»-^G^

lvi^-^\C'»-^~cA

l§ju^v^e~

£-}

t^iM^f^^s

/^-

cr\

/Q*^a4vA"'>^0 Cc/>^.

M-oi-

/_ /OcXLX_fivU-n

cu

Ci /liA

/vrtxxv—^>

(3 K

CflL/l/\>CJU»'

v

fvin^^i-j»

-^O, ^V-txtfH-^—-1^

v^^KxeZ

"Ifly) .

&

vL

4&C a-r^ &Ot O/

Ac*^l zX

Q

^

-^

\^^-Ctfs«-A-s^~-~p

1/i^A.c

1 ( A «—^*

r]/v\ lil/i

O cf^jULAj^.

/r

'

n /%

^ •

i/~i c)

^r^Axi

V/^

-U-tja-v^.

»—

crujixv--

(

-

_P °Jl-

P ^

>^A*-Q-AjZ-v>—-

L-o

n^xvlo^^.

-vva^xo

. U

•^^

———

——

m

ttv\

^"^J C/

Lxv<^La^^^ ^_

^./ I

"&.

N'-1

^j^i o~^-^»—.

c/

X2_^xx^tXJ2_CK

l^

"-/T

"^^rsv

.0 ^AA J—^ %_o 'S

-* Y^T——^>vv^

->^o ^^rtx '^^'VV/:PU^

T£ —•"rY^va/Tnry3 ^1 >? "7^°? YTT) -V°^5 ^7 ^ / \ ^r^f rx *- -^YJ —u°°^y^1

P ^*V^*/$JJ<\

-^t^Hrv^txv^^xr-iO

)•— ^o-vA^v/Tr^y^-^-o

]^r^

^ "TTp -• -~^ •

0

\.*\

UL

-

T

Jc^.

^

YV\ U\

Q

O

. ~\.

vCuoo^v

\ "*

dSL.

v_^

oA

q

•>/"

fe

-4*

^

a^>

(Lt

t^s

\^r^uw^'

a Q LA^QX^LO

> VJ^SL

v/-*-£-x**-

-

^YVv

0' fi

U^A

M Q

CX/KLXlAxj-CAy<-o—

A^QjJbt4>^.

^-<-^-<

64?

TVTCTV>'\--fy^^\

-t

Ll^TV01'

/V^A

c>~oJ\—«-t-&v4/v,

-^r-v_fvvo

cr~^xyvTo\A

—t-o-rv^xy^Vx

-tr~w(-\

}

j^

ixr

/(P^^pl^vyo

M}

u

-j^yr^Q

~v

VYTvvwv

G-

.

..

J[ ^. O

^

\

* £ fa ??i^&£*~^

I

\

6/7-7 o^ oU

X4

cT\MAxt>\a_&J-

A.G v \V\A.- Vft-fi^H^» i

M

(y\nt*AA-«r---.

ft d

dUj>(

* i

MJ22c,

dlxd

cuUZn (X.

J(^

C>i

(7

IL

fcr~\jL&*s--^>-~-£>

aa^uu^

[VM>/v-^v_p-a-fi

U \J/^

0

-TV»-^-

,

£

^J

^v-Or

r\"

II

dL CX/lA

dUj£JC£xxvje_P^-

CUAJZxjJCco^——o

l^-^A v

^a^A^JL

c/tA

CAATVV^P

cjL S- O

\

'•

*j -^3 /yr^\juyr^

-

0 On -

X

^~T\

_ //"

r>- —. ^ ^O r-t f*l ~&. A O fj

rt si

isl4sL&j2f

i wvwo

:3>u

^

-

~f

Juc^unaA

Vfl I- H C»-»'v_p'xo\-Aju<—*- ' « ^ .c ck_|XA.

n

(i

Jj

Q|

fl^

<\>f

A

5pA?

Vvo^vAA.

y o^v-ex»^^<-JcJc__

'

/v

j

1

\A

Y\ ^9 I \

1$^> ts^AL*——^

\±L*Jlx^*JC*-^_

(3

K^-\xl—C

V

V-iZ^-cZjUv

f \ \Ji |A/v-^>K_9

/)M

L-t ——

f]

~r-

'

i\

wW**.** 7^

y

&sne*cix

o

°v

-t/l**z>

^-

t?f

A /yJ-j OIXO-OA-*——OH3Z>"t

Q cTVa'—-^

a ^^x^ir^ fa^, S^^\ 4^^^.-<^ie^(^^

^vGv^_

J

^wo

ti<*>\£ ^U>ixyv>^A^ W Z. &U^ Jst, (h^ -&*£ «,' ~ xA-N ^ n \ a A I I W / I/ I .ti^U .'^- ^Oh^e clt^cX/ 64

rfj\.J\j*-a-JLJ?4. ' _-

Sl*^*i**&£ftf

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICES' DEBATING SOCIETY OF IRELAND

SESSION 1940-41,

OFFICERS ;-

HON. AUDITOR - - - - - Mr. Daminie M. Dowllng

HON. RECORD SECRETARY - - Mr. Rary 0'Connor

- - Mr. Louis V. Nolan

HON. CORR. SECRETARY

HON. TREASURER - - - - Mr. William J. Walsh

COMMITTEE :-

Miss Ada Hyland, B. A;

Mr. Liam D. Boyel

Mr. Brendan P. O'Byrne, B. A.

Mr. Mickael J. Egan, B. A. (Ex Auditor - Ex Offlei®)

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICES' DEBATING SOCIETY.

The closing Meeting of the 56th. Session of the Society _was held on the 14th. May 1940 in the Solicitors' Buildings, Pour Courts, Dublin. The Auditor Mr. Michael J. Egan, B.A. presided. The Minutes of the previous Meeting were read and signed without alteration. The Balance Sheet was read by the treasurer, Mr* Bowling. It showed that nearly £350- &ad passed through his hands during the Session, and also that all debts swing by and to tke Society had been cleared off. After some minor criticisms, the Balance Sheet was carried unanimously. Ballot papers was read by the Correspondence Secretary. The result of the election of Officers and Committee for the Session 1940-41 was then declared as follows:- Hon, Auditor ....................... Mr. Dominic M. Dowling. . * Hon. Record Secretary ........... '. ........... Mr. Rory 0' Connor. Hon. Corr. Secretary ....................... Mr. Louis V. Nolan. Hon. Treasurer ....................... Mr. William J. Walsh. Committee:- Miss Ada Hyland, B.A. Mr. Liam D. Boyd. » Mr. Brendan P. a'Byrne, B.A. Mr. Michael J. Egan, B.A.(Ex-Auditor, ex-officla) The Auditor then read his Report which was adopted. A list of those Members who had received and returned

The new Auditor and Committee then entered into office. Tke Auditor declared the awards of prizes for the Session v

1939-40 to be as follows:- ORATQRY : r~~ - - - "- - . »

Incorporated Law .Saciftty's Gold Medal

and Society's Certificate ...............Mr. M. J. Egan,

...............Mr. D.M.Dowling,

Society 1 s Silver Medal

...............Mr. L.D. Boyd,

Special Certificate

LEGAL DEBATE :

...............Mr. D.M. Dowling,

President's Gold Medal

...............Mr.P.P.0'Sullivan,

Society's Silver Medal

: Vice-Presielent'e Gold Medal

IMPROMPTU

.>.-..............Mr. Mi"J. Egan, Vice-president's Silver Medal ................Mr. B.P. O'Byrne,

IRISH DEBATE :

...... '........ .Mr. M. J. Bgan,

Society 1 s Gold. Medal

................Mr. E.W. Healy,

Society's Silver Medal

FIRST YEAR SPEECHES :

................Mr. S.A. Murtagh,

Society's Silver Medal

\ Mr. O'Byrne proposed and Mr. 0'Sullivan seconded a vote of

thanks to the outgoing Auditor and his Committee. Messrs. Walsh, Lynch, Kelly, Grotty, and the new Auditor, Mr. Dowling, associated themselves with the vote of thanks. The Motion was carried with acclamation. Mr. Lynch preposei and Mr. Crotty seconded the following Motion :- "That this House agrees with the statement of the President ©f the Incorporated Law Society that Irish is the cause of the low standard of answering in the Final Examination in Law for Solicitors Apprentices". Mr. Lynch proposing the Motion said that after the Ihter- -mediate an Apprentice gives one year of his course to Irish, the result being that he forgets any law he has learned for the Intermediate, and has to start from the beginning again. He also pointed out that no Scholarships had been awarded for some considerable time. Mr. Crotty secpnding said that the standard of answering in the Final had deteriorated since the passing of the Act. He also pointed out that Irish was of no practical use as there were no Law books in Irish. The following also spoke : Messrs. Durnin, McC^oskey and O'Byrne FOR the Motion, and Messrs. McGettigan, Egan, Kelly and Doyle AGAINST. The Motion was carried by 20 votes to 10 votes. The House then adjourned.

SIGNED

President Incorpbrated Law^ociety of Ireland.

DATED this 28th. day of October 194©-

TnCLLuOujUfJ:

ejAt

d SL <&t4

/$ferj#y f? Wt

' /- <^~) b /

O

\ 40 \Q&U4}

*S&t-ic&<2

tt '92fevX/ $> £

tjfe,

<2& AVVlTdRlfiL (£& au

frfa.

fitr&tAd^Xj

jfci CajQ&et y(

&~ rfted ^ef SiaufujCaLjf ^ 6/OA."

t

071

'A&fZ

jfi ?ilu) &b#i/^ ^

/ t tintfa fad

* 5^7 d? &&&J&

/n

a*vxS au

*UfA/5

??^^

mtffiMo

vn# *?> oil j*y *)**¥"?-$[ pn**v*3'\

y^yy^ pp™**?

f&**ra&fy £/;pyM?Ttfi

rvn ~yfy t *#pp»p Jf>

f»^r

*rsTT

sspTrr-ptrr

inrm ®a**mi

4^sr^ v^ -., , ffi^1^/7*^ ^rfs^y^^&^fr

jt^nj lob

~tta*jbj

Iftu) fl&veeK ffatnteAs.

c0>iclfct a+uJ

Sfa*vru+

^dfrwrzS

^ J /tir

neriiMd

K~, / <^C4^e^f^r/ y,j*e*t*i6a* , f.7-~0u*»f*n y ^.fya^ft', W&JXS, &Mt«fa£ t 0./>0'&^«i. 'fy«~,, T.^^Su****** , /V-rPuM&ef,

•+£*? Ga*/0u/c**Jta( t

£rAA_ ScxaufctJ" AfoA *^ ^~ 4»t

*jtu *u>/~J<*c^l!aout&

A-. / KX. ItOS*. t€*t44m*-* 'ly /TOC4. ^f^UUJff* 70uu^a i+ejui dsLcfctAxal dkJjuf^ , & £y*~^, ^I>u**u^ f pofa**, — XI » _X1 ^-

QUESTION

J&LCi+daJ jL^ aUCjL

Jr 3>x_ Jr. C.

%&ifln't& cuJi^

A~~*J{ ^«^4?

Ci4*alt£vi

JeJ JL £rJ*S&t

jfc ^zox/j oJ^ ifc- a~^^Q JLbsfc^ &

UX*4 JJol ^ tiZ

ttnai' uuo

**t*4X^C

C* ^*^lPC-

gsteandaof a^tjf JacffuuiJ. dec6ic/r- MjessrfS &

sl/0&*n* /UMiMju^esjf &«a ^U *

ofa&dL* SAauJJ fa

>£^£,

7&

^Zfe-c*.

£u*£3UA0X

fc UT&*dc(

•?&&**-

\

r^fcjL

&&/ aU- *t^4at. UXI& l

fr-s* -o. aJfecun*,* c Ijfy ffak*

,

t*Klx Uo Jt/>^f /facfcf Th Cudibx ti^[£ej &/* tifate \l~tM I .f ^ * - 4 ___ - /i UJMtm

\/

J* ^fa 6 &} /&nn$i/t+

fa*

T.C. o

vo re

r#/wxs.

/**-

L

f*Jt

c_«sc

•****

*s* JLJL

MOTION.

>^7 exM* * t**7eocluc4_ &

ntfcjis J4cLA*nf JLs

Of

t to

S7

IMt

~*aun*a O*Ji to*ar Sis, L

G&taJtot*** too*

MOTION.

0XfU*

*7A- 0'

. " S.

MSJSKS

0 *

GO.

// o'

£rt£A/Lc4 i~> &f*dcU*Zf'

*fix*n6e*/?W. X ^^^feyi«£*^/

AJ&U/ anal &&n*ijaF

UC^ 4£~&C4e£^OL~*0{

\J^Ur fa£*sfa*ej'aS U*«««»lj Jktf " i9*r'

&L

4km* -ib vxar&£*

*r d&*t**4tr

Mr/ce.

&*CU*lCLA

»

V* C'gu**c

0*4

s **?

I/.

, J*«

file 0 '

/ *l tOO-S. /ICUS-Cof CjbL&S/U**

/MMJt

J#t£

\/0t*A (ermine ,3)fjL&n. &**.

(DOS Lu&e£*d , eebnot / /' X /

-^f^M

~v

-&

3*^*7'

'r'

A^i/*-T? ^-v^.

W->OT-C—n^rVv^l~~*Tp —^v-j"!

V7'3r'O^E—t?^

e--—i»—£""7

P

ft

y^-^u

">HX"

K"-o

^Vj C1—*-~>-«i^tr«n

•yo—^tO~4

c-a—0^ V

^-^^^

•^

Oo-C

<*->fc"c

Vr

rrro cr?i^~f "

t**_xtX^ ''-p-tll^.

^

a.

Fe-r

^=g_

60-0^?.

£>'--£-(-££

.

^2_5^»-r^^r

&L,

(P^f^^A

fa—f-c^fT^f**-^) -*™>

''vt- fr^-rv-6-

«fcc, Jtaafl a ^e^w

OSL

/

* Jzve tifc

/fe

MOTION Nor/C£

dw> £<** W^*£/ ^t & ^/^ S7 Vc*^<£/ i. s?;4^fc/^ ^ ^/'*- ? aJLfaJ.

7%*- We//**, euas

J# O/Jitn^riitJ C4*w*xadtor $***> &&&£ ^7 ftte/anflj M * ' . .'6 ,-,/..!-

Nonce,

dual

* 0'

*n

0'&**w

&. ^71*

ffi* J*rCf0XAJ»r&

Morion.

srzr>i^-e_

ftfvrudii^. *>/

to*** O*LCL

7n£*4j J*

tf^Jts^ 4 *~ * W

AuS

'SJXf. UtASW.

X" tffc

MOTION.

f vL 7W4U

Q.r.

c } -~ / , Sea*tu* {. O 0*0**

~f

\ U U/te&n.

Ofairtf/' ^Y*^^ -

TW

"*>

rmrff

i? yr>o

entry

'

f vwioQ

***>}

-uaff

*>:& "pav w

t

-So

/

r

Ulous

oust*

, jfc, Jai

AM

£KJ£s

j&#&ajr

J-

dud A

(3

On

OJI

, fvuf

&A

em

AtouX

O«.

UrtA*.

/

/fet

ll*H4

J(OUJ2^S

u*

fitUL <£-<*

jtouat

tfail* U*

. 4ot? &****

crn

%**.

*; " fajT tfci*

0' 6r**tax

&m

DEBATE.

.

-73k

&

C

t

G£je ^r

/

bid)

£2 faJ&A Q«0(

skSh ficints

O. TT

JQ>tA#&

Kf

&rvn\'JJjLk.

t/L

en

ik.

skew.

f

*

( t

dt&SS a/ td$

f Jzr* t- €<*&*&+

cJT // &' CJCocJi,

.

,

tytr&ii Jvx.

TZa.

^a/* /fa. clttLC^t^r^

3.

#*

w«9

ru

S0l*TtOJ-ry*

TOW

72n**

&

OK,

W

rn*z*T*r On

**rn*Jil<>

Giin

*ry&0-

0ty

*"*"*>

77

Q.r.

MbT\ON.

.

-ftcrud.. &ks-e.y ,

*

***

r

w

*

&4Les

^e

&***+*

tt^fo -3cUZ

^r

On Gtolt^cuty

tit. -

<&&/ CM

(j.C.J)

(/

f

<^L

jLtA&£jQ0t 0*&*JcA

Morion,

MdT/OH ca ifWee .

££

MOTION

fonoN

&L /fofvf£.

&rrr2#nlJtuL fa

faf.

fab

do

M

£

It/I

f K€

if

£/ (j

O

*#i

£o-

ly

a

L

aJi0itAj9Viaf As if

1004 aJ&A ft < v

nt

-*-&Jr t^^s^7 '>*&

~j-e —— rfr>

<=istr*—JZ-

sli*-tr-t~f

-v»^vt^O

y*-

-UH

~"v*<-£-«7

g

n

/a

A W

F^

y^c5^~^p {3wf*4<*j

.M

f

1*

^'

ffl*J)t*&*t*ili

£UCL*

0fe+ edb(

jkrCAa^.

. B

Q. f.

Unfit

cu+al

fa

{2* <^/

6

,

^r

a

A.

u*

.

*

r

oortHc,.

Jfc, &*A*Jt £.*

: 4&

U*.

L+L

>f CL ~D zjft c s:

d>' O

!>

O

as

Mi

h

Jy

c(&

V

^T

"*5~

&enxx

f ' _ . X" 4 QuMfarH J

VT, &/— - CUAfUCCTfLA ^TSe^. Jaffa b&J* M

uwfr fj&aAot jT^krJ* *' • -^ *

^^ X C&jUJ*Q£f

4—— » ff^»WLli**9! /-^

J*.

& J£~

Oirrrt fcr*0 ."

7%*

.

f

*

Morion.

- n >/- ^ i/ ffr >(& P/}/ . f^ccjJKiJLt^A -4, &<*>#: qfarf

0.T

X

/r % J>«*^*>? <^"» *i /

MOnoH ON

^2/~ &, /f™Jf t* & &

J* m fCl-SZAcl

_

_

\

"

&&n.&la~^ r\

ON

iu^ JOT? a

JU^/fasc* <±j}

tiJst, 3£yJ, 4'&w*«

fJ0*!K&US2SH& fa

Vfv ^ -&t *4GLus#o/

Q.r.

KZC ft* gm/ttui** "£7 y. £>kj. "*%'<*

*V&JL^

AJ JLl &f %fa /^auo&Uf Sad fae*^ &eCAS/

-~/^r 6U**bf0x.

*

J/r /fan. *-*

at

SJL

a)

/&jUbJ fiLf Ou^>

_ j

.*r

-

f

--

.

~ *-* ——•

/ s!\

/£/<

6&S A JLu/ 0>rzs*7/ri£/ £~#*4 ty( fy**)> a&i&l & Cudifex. Alb Jiff

cuL^ti^ 0nrmM& ^7 dtr^oc^^t^ una&L t »

fflJic£A& &i*Ji C0r*j>n

fr»Z>

. & o i^6'a^U,

Bf*4n&t

fy

1?bi

yy

SOLICITORS' APPRENTICES* DEBATING- SOCIETY OF IRELAND

SESSION

1941-42

OFFICERS :-

HON. AUDITOR

Mr. Patrick P. O'SullIvan, B.A

HON. RECORD SECRETARY

- - Mr. Gerard M. Doyle,

HON. CORH. SECRETARY

- - Mr. Rory 0'Connor.

HON. TREASURER

- - - - Mr. George A. Russell.

COMMUTES :-

Mr. James L. B^rne

Miss Joan

Domhnall MacEiteaghain..

Mr. Dominic M. Bowling, (Ex-Auditor, ex-offioio)

SOLICITOUS' APPRENTICES' DEBATING- SOCIETY OF IB2LAMD

The closing Meeting of the 57th Session of the society was held on the 19th May 1941 in the Solicitors' Buildings, Pour Courts, Dublin. The Auditor Mr. Dominic M. Dowling presided. The Minutes of the previous Meeting were read and signed without alteration. The Balance Sheet was read by the Treasurer, Mr.Walsh.. It showed that over £300. had passed through his hands during the Session. All debts owing by the Society had been paid. After some minor criticisms, the Balance Sheet was carried unanimously. The Auditor then read his report which was passed with acclamation. A list of those Members who had received and returned Ballot ' papers was read by the Correspondence Secretary. The result of the - election of Officers and Committee for the Session 1941-42 was then declared as follows :- Hon. Auditor .................. Mr. Patrick P.0'Sullivan, B.A. Hon. Record Secretary .................. Mr. Grerard M. Doyle. Hon. Corr. Secretary .................. Mr. Sory 0'Connor. Hon. Treasurer .................. Mr. G-eorge A. Russell. Committee:-

Mr. James L. Byrne. Miss Joan MacdKilay. Domhnall MacEiteaghain. Mr. Dominic M. Dowling, (Ex-Auditor, ex oYicio)

The new Auditor and Committee then entered into office. The Auditor declared the awards of prizes for the Session

1940-41 to be as follows :- QBATQHY: :

Incorporated Law Society's Sold Medal and society's Certificate

...............Mr. D. M. Dowling, ...............Mr. L. D. Boyd, - ...............Mr. L. 7. Uolan, *

Society's Silver Medal Special Certificate

-

-'

'

:

LEGAL DBBATB

...............Mr. B. J. Durnin, ...............Mr. L. V. Uolan,

President's G-old Medal Society's Silver Medal

IMPBOMTU :

Vice-President's Gold Medal ..................Mr. D. M. Cowling, Vice-President's Silver Medal ..................Mr. L. V. Nolan,

IBISE DEBATE :

..................Mr. J. L. Byrne,

Society's Sold Medal

..................Mr. E.P.McMorrow,

Society's Silver Medal

FLRST YEAB SPEAKBH3 :

Society's silver Medal ..................Mr. J.L.Byrne, Mr. Brendan O'Byrne proposed and Mr. Liam Oollins seconded a vote of thanks to the outgoing Auditor and his Committee. Messrs. Durnin and Boyd associated themselves with the vote of thanks. The Motion was carried with acclamation. Mr. Hory G'Connor proposed and Mr. O'Byrne seconded the following Motion :- "That We the Members of this Society humbly petition the Minister for Justice, to introduce, as soon as possible, legislation to amend the Legal Practitioners (Qualification) Act 1929 in either of two ways:- (a) By deleting from the Act all reference to a 'Second Examination in Irish' for Solicitors' Apprentices, or (b) by making provision to render less difficult such 'Second Examination in Irish". Mr. 0'Connor proposing the Motion said that the very high standard required in the Examination was an enormous handicap to Solicitors' Apprentices who through no fault of their own had little knowledge of the Irish language. He pointed out that having regard to the work to be done, apprenticeship to be served, and examinations to be passed by those becoming solicitors the addition of Irish to the curriculum renders the task of solicitors' Apprentices excessively burdensome and consequently lowers the standard of his or her knowledge of law. Mr. O'Byrne seconding the Motion, suggested that the standard of the "First" Irish should be raised, and that the "Second" Irish should be abolished. Messrs. Collins, G-off and Hutley spoke for the Motion and Messrs. Doyle, Nolan, O'Sullivan and MacEiteaghain spoke against the Motion. The Motion was declared carried. The House then adjourned.

SIGHED ... . 4 .*

President Incorporated Law Society of Ireland.

BATED this 29th day of October 1941.

<7

/

~4

0?

"**^**

^Cc^t^. ^u^^e^f £*

tf4 A^. f ^ •

" " • -

-

-

*.

J?

A

/ '

' ^'

i

^<*t~r

<^e,/^^-i. —e-e/

x<£***^

A

0 . Ms.

<$

^a

4

*?

J& <*#»~^

tfl S/fr

frj2^-A-<^£.

_«-y

-

V*/

*?6*V 4

£ *>*rt>

*/

'-6

A4

«~rfif

&

^f

*£.

7**+ *

-

*z

-4**rrx-&e?.

~*<-=ZJZ.

*io~~Zi^-& Y i&*c~£,'

t&

^V-^^e

y

<& -1^£^£t

r at*-cA V.

•*& ^u^t^i

.

'

-titx^C-c-C. ~&^i&

'

ff

*6u(. ^£

s6?~+~++&iCt.

xiXi

&***+*<**

//f*j *£ *^&*~&

sOt^j&sdn

4*- 0

'O vJ^t^^aX'^A. , jZ«L&+*

, Wld&US

& ,-> C-£*^~

^

—~-~ O

-7

7

r

Q I

-

^£a^o«

^ ^v.

st+

jU

,y S&JL

^

p

<2+vX*.'&.

j XA

+&

-&*-'ffics'0

/%*

^>*0C*i $ %*

*y,

/

X

-

^

A>

4Ls*/

'

^7

/-cJe**^^

JF

ree^e.***^

,«*••»%»

-«^-^«^

f - —^-,— ^ ———--

^

s&Jts&j&^^Ze-at J^f .

^7^

tfs^^TtfK'

/<•-**•€

tZo^c*

^

~*^>/* ~*^£-t' '6^'

^£&>£^*&

s&c-

«*^2-<^4L

-Iv'*

•^^t*<*H^-—t^

y& /&2<&i

**& *-**~><£'2>

S%Si^

f^xW./ '

'/•-.

,. "

/t /****

* .^-i^+^^a^s^-s

stf6*^1**^*^-

-r %Tju^Z^.<9

&>/

S ^ /**.

C • ^r- -x>ci*ts7Zj.

4fo-^

&*-

£i0-*j£4**j*

^i^£-<^

'^^t-^^

^- &**&&£i "~-

/^^J2

sttmt H*<. <4£&^

-*x*eo

^4i&<£*S .

4 S&f.

/*£v x^A**' ^

v^*«

r

*

r

<2

\^u^-

'+i-£*JZ&

-&7*4K*!St*

rf/

^ &S

* X * y WT

^*v^^v -«*x&-o *#. 9-

~4/ ?%*

#7

/

<%?

^TV^^a^p

t?

*-J^ -4r

~>

V*

7

Uo^o^f S ti-

W/

*

7 -aJLyg^

x?

O

0

tfc.

/I

&S

^.0

•£•

,2t

// &Z&&4

,4J**

&o -^S-

.

<2*C&~~«^<^.

//C&Kl&f *sl#L

«^X^

&^

.A*—-£ xt*

i) -aJU^k

~a+*y

At~j*^

J?

^i^&* Sj?

-4+1

J**^t

'

. y**^

s*>^

<2? X^'

V

£*'

/

r

&

/

V .

&* ^t^^i P^t*. f&+&*6&

0*"

•j9&*t*t^

&-*-

^iJZ&^tJL**, ~fc.

-T*

£

r

/

*.

«i

#U OmZ&fi -i»4r

.

.^**i^

^

ts

.''^gsteaft.a

s

/a&&ws£4#' *^T

^a

J

7&-J?. 4

oX

c^

' utg

3"

/

tss

u:. ^ >««^^:

,47

\

^& A/

/

40

/*•

<7

U-

/

7%*.

} .

£n. A<^***t>.

**<^ £*&&&.

^c-fo**** fa^.

»ez^£<**->-**^i- ,

P.

<7

4?

<7

47-

r

sy

&

*^**

•**%:

«?-

,-

7

1

^~7^

%?> 'srzx^j,

4^v*>Jf $ F**2

*> s???

l\

*7

P

rf

S2

.4h+ts»t4/

-

4+

J <<*

^r?

^X^>

*&+&! -+* sl&^^^y r

£/

. /

A

jrf

'"7

(7

, ....

___

. __

_

.„ /Cc^^.

o2^4 ^^^

X?

^

si*-~p#i&*t rffa^

j£ ^£^aUL0-

Made with FlippingBook HTML5