ASSOCIATE Magazine FBINAA Q2-2026

DISRUPTION OF JUSTICE

FBINAA.ORG | Q2 2026

I n response, some subjects resort to suicide. Subject suicide events increase risk to law enforcement and civilians, interrupt the justice process, and create operational and legal challenges for law enforcement agencies. If a subject dies by suicide, whether by their own doing or in a “suicide by cop” scenario, the interruption to the criminal justice process denies survivors and victims’ families closure and healing. Additionally, the com munity may perceive these interrupted cases as system failures or unlawful uses of force, illustrating the importance of better understanding and preventing these events. Subjects can commit suicide at any point in an investigation or phase of the criminal justice process. For example, individuals who learn they are under investigation via media coverage, law enforcement investigative contact, indictments and warrants, or from the victim directly, may end their lives before law enforce ment can execute an arrest. In other instances, the subject dies by suicide during or after trial. When a considerable amount of time has passed between the date of the offense and when approached by law enforcement, the subject’s behavior may be unpredictable due to changes in life circumstances, positive or negative. In some instances, the subject was strongly connected with their community, even holding positions of power, respect, or prestige, before being linked to a violent crime that occurred decades prior. Potential risk factors for subject suicide include stressors, such as a sudden loss of freedom, financial hardship, custody disputes, and ongoing interpersonal conflict (Mohandie et al., 2009; Parent and Parent, 2021). Despite examples of sub ject suicides being publicized in local and national news, little research exists on individuals who suicide in response to being under investigation or apprehension for violent crimes. In a small subset of incidences, some subjects harm oth ers before dying by suicide. In a sample of deadly use of force incidents, bystanders and other non-law enforcement person nel were injured (12%) or killed (3%) in 15% of scenarios. Law enforcement officers (LEOs) were injured (18%) or killed (1%) in 19% of scenarios (Mohandie et al., 2009). Individuals with mental health concerns and/or diagnoses, previous suicidal ideation or attempts, emotional distress, or substance use issues are more likely to attack bystanders or police (Mohandie et al., 2009; Par ent and Parent, 2021). Avoiding detection or apprehension and suicidality are among the top offender motivations for lethal violence against law enforcement (Van Allen et al., 2024). Other subjects provoke LEOs into deadly confrontations with the goal

SUBJECTS WHO DIE BY SUICIDE DURING INVESTIGATIONS OF SEXUAL ASSUALTS AND HOMICIDES

KATHLEEN ALLEN, M.A.

When a case remains unsolved for an extended period, a subject may believe they have evaded detection. Recent advances in forensic technology, particularly through DNA, provide hope for solving challenging cases. As investigative efforts are renewed, subjects may realize their identification and subsequent arrest is no longer avoidable.

continued on page 18

17