Life and Death Planning for Retirement Benefits

253 / 507

Chapter 5: Roth Retirement Plans 253
See regarding the effect of a recharacterization on calculation of the required minimum
distribution.
Here are the requirements for effecting a recharacterization:
1. Recharacterization is accomplished by moving the recharacterized traditional or Roth IRA
contribution to the other type of IRA (Roth or traditional) by direct trustee-to-trustee transfer
following the required notifications (see #3). A “60-day rollover” may not be used. Reg
A-1(a). See for the difference.
2. Not only the original contribution but “any net income attributable to such contribution”
must be transferred. Reg. A-2(a). See
3. The election to recharacterize is made by providing notice and directions to the IRA
sponsors involved, on or before the date of the transfer, to carry out the transfer of funds or property
directly from the transferring IRA into the transferee IRA. Reg. A-6(a).
4. The election to recharacterize “cannot be revoked” after the transfer to the other type of
IRA has occurred. Reg. A-6(b).
5. A recharacterization is “never treated as a rollover for purposes of the one-rollover-per-
year limitation ..., even if the contribution would have been treated as a rollover contribution by
the ...[transferee] IRA if it had been made directly to the” transferee IRA in the first place. Reg.
A-8. See regarding the one rollover per year limitation.
6. A Roth conversion that comes from a nonIRA plan B)) is recharacterized by
moving the converted amount (and earnings) out of the Roth IRA and into a traditional IRA, NOT
back into the traditional nonIRA plan it was in prior to the Roth conversion. See Notice 2008-30,
2008-12 IRB 638, A-5, A-7.
7. A “regular” contribution made to either type of IRA for a particular year may be
recharacterized as a contribution to the other type, by transferring the contribution (together with
the “net income attributable” to the contribution) to the other type of IRA.
5.6.04 Partial recharacterizations
Partial recharacterizations are permitted. Reg. A-1(a).
However, you cannot “cherry pick” the assets you recharacterize so as to recharacterize
only the “losers.” If a participant converted his IRA to a Roth IRA at a time when the account
contained 100 shares of Acme and 100 shares of Omega, and then a few months later the Acme
had appreciated but the Omega had declined in value, the participant might like to recharacterize
just the Omega stock. But the regulation’s definition of the “income” on the account (the income
that must be transferred to a traditional IRA along with the contribution being recharacterized; see
is based on the appreciation and depreciation of the entire account, not of the particular
assets you might choose to recharacterize. Reg. A-2(c)(5), (c)(6), Example 2.
If an individual converts his IRA to multiple Roth IRAs, the regulations permit him to
“unconvert” one or more of the multiple Roths without undoing all of them. See Reg.
A-2(b), (c)(5), and (6), Example 2. Thus, a client might consider converting his IRA into several
Roth IRAs, with portfolio assets whose values are less likely to move in tandem placed into
separate Roth IRAs. That way, if one asset class declines in value prior to the deadline for