2017 HSC Section 2 - Practice Management

188 / 240

Russ et al Annals of Surgery Volume 258, Number 6, December 2013
TABLE 1.
(Continued
)
Authors
Year
Type of Checklist
Outcome Assessed
∗
Study Methodology
†
Country
Setting
Surgical Specialty
Paige et al
31
2008 Patient-specific
preoperative briefingchecklist
Quality of teamwork (eg,
team orientation,accountability,communication)
360
◦
ratings of self and peers
(real ORs)—pre/post
(The study lasted 7 months in
total. No additionalinformation regarding timingsprovided.)
USA, Alaska
1 rural community
hospital
General surgery
Berenholtz
32
2009 1-page, patient-specific,
preoperative briefingand postoperativede-briefing checklist
Interdisciplinary
communication andteamwork
Surveys—post(Data collection commenced 15
months after checklistimplementation)
USA, Baltimore 1 tertiary academic
center
Multispecialty
Henrickson et al
33
2009 Patient-specific
preoperative briefingchecklist
Surgical flow disruptions
related tomiscommunication
Observations (real
ORs)—pre/post
(Postobservations were carried
out 7 days after briefingimplementation)
USA
1 tertiary academic
center
Cardiovascular
Einav et al
34
2010 Patient-specific
preoperative briefingchecklist (presentedin poster format in allORs)
Near-misses associated with
problematic teamwork
Observations (real
ORs)—pre/post
(preobservations lasted 3 months,
postobservations ingynecology took place 5months later and lasted 3months, observations inorthopedics took place 10months later and lasted 3months)
Israel, Jerusalem 1 tertiary care
hospital
Gynecology and
orthopedics
Nilsson et al
35
2010 WHO Surgical Safety
Checklist
“Team feeling” in the OR Surveys—post
(Data collection lasted for 3
weeks 1 yr after the checklisthad been implemented)
Sweden,
Ostergotland
2 Swedish hospitals Multispecialty
Papaspyros et al
36
2010 Patient-specific
preoperative briefingand postoperativede-briefing checklist
Quality of communication Interviews—Post
(No information was provided
regarding timings)
UK, Leeds
1 university hospital Cardiac surgery
Calland et al
37
2011 Patient-specific safety
checklist with pre-,intra-, andpostoperativecomponents
Team coordination and
communication.
Surveys and observations (from
video recordings of realORs)—RCT
(The study lasted 15 months in
total.)
USA, Virginia 1 university hospital General surgery—
laparoscopiccholecystectomyprocedures only
(continued
)
C 2013 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
166