9
Morningstar FundInvestor
October 2016
dividend growth and buy only when a stock is under-
valued based on a range of outcomes incorporating
a variety of macroeconomic scenarios, holding
40
or
so names. Gold-rated
Oakmark Select
OAKLX
,
concentrated in only about
20
names, takes an abso-
lute value approach and comes in at
0
.
97
.
Some Growth Funds Look Like the Best Values
Large-growth funds top the list of funds with the
lowest price/fair value ratios. At the end of
2014
, only
one fund, Silver-rated
RiverPark/Wedgewood
RWGFX
, had a ratio below
1
.
0
. That fund remains one
of the better deals, with a ratio of
0
.
93
today. Today,
however, it is joined by
24
other large-growth funds
with ratios below
1
.
0
, including Gold-rated
Harbor
Capital Appreciation
HACAX
at
0
.
96
. To be sure, there
are growth funds at the other extreme, with
Clear-
Bridge Aggressive Growth
SHRAX
topping the list at
1
.
06
. Overall, though, funds in this category are more
likely to be good deals, as measured by Morningstar’s
price/fair value ratio.
Finding Value With Less Volatility
Dividend-oriented strategies are the traditional
territory for stock investors seeking stability. Current
valuations pose a challenge for valuation-sensitive
investors who are also wary of volatility. For example,
Morgan Stanley Institutional Growth
MSEGX
looks like a better deal than most dividend-oriented
funds today, with a price/fair value ratio of
0
.
99
,
but it was also recently downgraded to Silver from Gold
because its volatility has made it difficult for share-
holders to stay the course. It is still an excellent choice
for those who can handle the ride, but not an
alternative for investors looking for core exposure
that’s more staid.
We sorted through those funds with price/fair value
ratios of
0
.
96
or less—few of which were large-
value funds—seeking Morningstar Medalists with
lower volatility than Vanguard
500
Index. Two
names stood out with lower standard deviations than
the benchmark over the past five- and
10
-year
periods. Silver-rated
Bridgeway Blue Chip 35 Index
BRLIX
has the highest average market cap of any
U.S. equity mutual fund, holding mature industry titans
with steadier records of profitability, stronger balance
sheets, and lower volatility than their smaller-cap
brethren, and the fund’s strategy of equal-weighting
its holdings further reduces stock-specific risk.
Parnassus Core Equity also made the cut. The managers
look for companies with strong competitive advan-
tages, increasingly relevant products or services, quality
management, and temporarily depressed valuations.
They argue that their environmental, social, and gover-
nance criteria help them avoid firms prone to corporate
scandals and other risks.
That’s not to say these funds are the best deals now
or appropriate for everyone. Besides, volatile funds can
pay off nicely in the long run. A ranking by Sharpe
ratio, which allows for a comparison of risk-adjusted
performance across categories, shows that the
highly volatile Morgan Stanley Institutional Growth
has bested Vanguard
500
Index on a risk-adjusted
basis over the past decade. Investors planning to sit
tight for another
10
years have less to fear.
K
Contact Laura Lallos at
laura.lallos@morningstar.comCheapest and Priciest Portfolios
Fund
Ticker
Category
Price/Fair Value
Morningstar Medalists With the Lowest Price/Fair Value Ratios
RiverPark/Wedgewood Retail
RWGFX
Large Growth
0.93
American Century Ultra
TWCUX
Large Growth
0.95
Invesco Comstock
ACSTX
Large Value
0.95
Parnassus
PARNX
Large Growth
0.95
Morningstar Medalists With the Highest Price/Fair Value Ratios
ClearBridge Aggressive Growth
SHRAX
Large Growth
1.06
American Funds Invmt Co of America
AIVSX
Large Blend
1.04
Fidelity Growth Company
FDGRX
Large Growth
1.04
Neuberger Berman Socially Rspns
NRAAX
Large Growth
1.04
T. Rowe Price Dividend Growth
PRDGX
Large Blend
1.04
TIAA-CREF Growth & Income Instl
TIGRX
Large Growth
1.04
Vanguard Dividend Appreciation Idx
VDAIX
Large Blend
1.04
Based on each fund’s most recent portfolio, calculated as of Sept. 23, 2016.