103 / 220
Table
2.
Comparison of Surgical Outcomes Between Total Thyroidectomy
+
Prophylactic Central Neck Dissection (Group A)
and Total Thyroidectomy Alone (Group B)
No. of postoperative
hypocalcemia (%)
No. of recurrent
laryngeal nerve injury (%)
First author
No. of postoperative
RAI ablation (%)
Temporary
Permanent
Temporary
Permanent
No. of hematoma
formation (%)
No. of wound
infection/seroma (%)
Total
morbidity
a
(%)
Roh (17)
na
A
=
13 (32.5)
B
=
7 (9.6)
na
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
3 (4.1)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
2 (2.7)
A
=
1 (2.5)
B
=
1 (1.4)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
14 (35.0)
B
=
13 (17.8)
Choi (18)
A
=
48 (100)
B
=
53 (100)
A
=
8 (16.7)
B
=
6 (11.3)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
1 (1.9)
A
=
1 (2.1)
B
=
0 (0.0)
na
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
9 (18.8)
B
=
7 (13.2)
Bardet (19)
na
na
na
na
na
na
na
—
Perrino (20)
na
A
=
8 (8.7)
B
=
11 (6.9)
A
=
3 (3.2)
B
=
2 (1.3)
A
=
3 (3.3)
B
=
5 (3.1)
A
=
1 (1.1)
B
=
4 (2.5)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
1 (0.6)
A
=
15 (16.3)
B
=
23 (14.5)
Costa (21)
A
=
87 (69.0)
B
=
62 (52.5)
na
na
na
na
na
na
—
Zuniga (22)
A
=
79 (58.1)
B
=
55 (42.3)
na
na
na
na
na
na
—
Moo (23)
A
=
31 (68.9)
B
=
26 (72.2)
A
=
14 (31.1)
B
=
2 (5.6)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
2 (5.6)
A
=
2 (4.4)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
na
na
A
=
16 (35.6)
B
=
4 (11.1)
Hughes (24)
A
=
72 (92.3)
B
=
56 (86.2)
A
=
21 (26.9)
B
=
5 (7.7)
A
=
2 (2.6)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
2 (3.1)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
na
A
=
1 (1.3)
B
=
2 (3.1)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
1 (1.5)
A
=
24 (30.8)
B
=
10 (15.4)
Popadich (25)
na
A
=
25 (9.7)
B
=
14 (4.0)
A
=
2 (0.8)
B
=
2 (0.6)
A
=
1 (0.4)
B
=
8 (2.3)
A
=
1 (0.4)
B
=
6 (1.7)
A
=
5 (1.9)
B
=
3 (0.9)
A
=
3 (1.2)
B
=
5 (1.4)
A
=
37 (14.3)
B
=
38 (11.0)
So (26)
A
=
101 (84.9)
B
=
92 (81.4)
A
=
49 (41.2)
B
=
38 (33.6)
A
=
7 (5.9)
B
=
2 (1.8)
A
=
4 (3.4)
B
=
4 (3.5)
A
=
1 (0.8)
B
=
2 (1.8)
A
=
1 (0.8)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
64 (53.8)
b
B
=
46 (40.7)
Lang (7)
A
=
62 (75.6)
B
=
63 (61.2)
A
=
15 (18.3)
B
=
9 (8.7)
A
=
2 (2.4)
B
=
1 (1.2)
A
=
3 (3.7)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
1 (1.2)
B
=
1 (1.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
1 (1.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
21 (25.6)
B
=
12 (11.7)
Wang (27)
A
=
35 (71.4)
B
=
12 (32.4)
A
=
21 (42.9)
B
=
4 (10.8)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
3 (8.3)
A
=
1 (2.0)
B
=
1 (2.7)
na
na
na
A
=
22 (44.9)
B
=
8 (21.6)
Raffaelli (28)
na
A
=
53 (42.7)
B
=
11 (17.7)
A
=
1 (0.8)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
1 (0.8)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
1 (0.8)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
0 (0.0)
B
=
0 (0.0)
A
=
56 (45.2)
B
=
11 (17.7)
Barczynski (29)
A
=
231 (64.5)
B
=
79 (28.0)
A
=
109 (30.4)
B
=
37 (13.1)
A
=
8 (2.2)
B
=
2 (0.7)
A
=
26 (7.3)
B
=
18 (6.4)
A
=
9 (2.5)
B
=
6 (2.1)
na
na
A
=
152 (42.5)
B
=
63 (22.3)
a
The sum of all complications; same patient with more than two complications was counted as one.
b
Including two chyle leaks.
83