Eternal India
encyclopedia
MUSIC
HINDUSTANI AND KARNATAK MUSIC
There is much in common between Hin-
dustani music and Karnatak music. There are
also points of difference. The singing and
playing in Indian music can be slow, medium
or fast and this determines the tempo. North
Indian music has explored the possibilities of
the slow tempo and it accelerates in minimal
gradations. In South Indian music the medium
tempo is precisely the double of the slow and
the fast precisely the double of the medium.
North Indian music has fewer Talas and
they are not organised in any systematic man-
ner. Another distinguishing feature is the em-
phasis placed on the characteristic drum pat-
tern of each Tala in North Indian music. Two
Talas might have the same duration and sub-
divisions but have different drum patterns.
Unlike South Indian music, a gradual accel-
eration of tempo leading to a final climax is a
characteristic feature of North Indian music.
“The basic scale of modem North Indian
music is heptatonic and its seven notes called
nadja, mabha, gandhara, madhyama, pan-
chama, dhaivata and nisada, abbreviated to
Sa, ri, ga, ma, pa, dha and ni correspond
approximately to those of the European major
scale. They may be elaborated with half-tones
of varying intervals classified according to the
number of srutis they contain. The shruti is a
theoretical interval of which the scale contains
22
. •
“There is no developed harmony in Indian
music and the melody which usually proceeds
by conjunct intervals (i.e adjacent notes on the
keyboard), never suggests a harmonic basis,
as do many European melodies. The tune is
sustained by one or more drone notes and by
drumming. The melodic line and the subtle
and complex cross rhythms of Indian music
take the place of harmony and counterpoint in
the ear of the trained listener.”
— A. L. Basham
Coming to the musical forms, the Dhru-
pad of Hindustani music was first shaped by
Raja Mansingh Tomar of Gwalior and devel-
oped by Swami Haridas and his disciple,
Tansen, who was a luminary of Akbar's court.
It preserves the antique liturgical stateliness in
its style. It begins with a free melodic elabo-
ration or Alap and goes on to a rhythm-bound
lyric whose first two sections traverse pro-
gressively the lower, middle and upper oc-
taves while the last two sections can be re-'
garded as the complex development of the
same material. There are only a very few
practitioners of this style today.
The Khayal (a word of Persian origin
meaning "imagination") probably originated
with Amir Khusrau, the Persian aristocrat and
humanist of the 13th century. It was devel-
oped by Sultan Sharqui of the 15th century
and established as a classical style by Sada-
rang Nyamat Khan of the 18th century. The
structure of the Khayal is considerably re-
laxed. It is rarely that singing begins with the
Alap or free melodic elaboration. More often
the Alap is done in the melodic elaboration of
the phrases of the composition itself. There is
an extensive exploration of all possible re-
sources of the Gamak, the type of movement
from one note to another which includes
shakes, trills, glides, swings, spiralling accents
and numerous other graces.
The Khayal later proliferated into many
gharanas or schools. The oldest, the Gwalior
Gharana, is distinguished by open-throated
singing, formal simplicity and straight, linear
transitions from note to note. The Agra Ghar-
ana is close to the Dhrupad in its disciplined
execution but loves dramatic contrasts and
rhythmic syncopations. The Rangeela Ghar-
ana evolved as a modulation of this style
towards greater lyrical warmth and colour.
The Kirana Gharana has a slow tempo, avoids
dramatic contrasts and tensions and is sweet,
serene and soothing. The Patalia Gharana spe-
cialises in spectacular rhythm play.
In South Indian music the main group is
composed of 35 Talas. Each Tala is composed
of one, two or three different units: short, me-
dium and long. The medium unit is twice the
duration of the short. The long unit, however,
may be three, four, five, seven or nine times
the duration of the short. There are seven basic
Tala patterns - Dhruva, Mathya, Rupaka,
Jhampa, Triputa, Ata and Eka Tala. Each Tala
may be performed in either slow, medium or
quick tempo. There is no gradual acceleration
of tempo as in North Indian music.
"A study of the two styles indicates that
the basic difference is in the articulation of the
gamakas (graces). In Carnatic music the oscil-
lation of notes is much faster than in Hindus-
tani music. The bane of Carnatic music is the
excessive undulation of almost every note
with the result that it becomes difficult to
identify the note which is actually being sung.
"Carnatic music in the last 20 years has be-
come hyper-intellectual, teeming with intri-
cate combinations both in swara and tala con-
struction. This doubtless is an indication of the
intellectual brilliance of South India but art
basically is and must be emotion-oriented.
Otherwise it is merely craft. (M.R. Gautam,
"The Musical Heritage of India.'')
LIGHT CLASSICAL FORMS
In addition to the major form of the
Khayal,
the northern Hindustani system has produced
a rich variety' of light classical forms. In
Tarana,
the tempo is generally fast, the syllables which
have no articulate meaning are used for tonal
values. The Tappa, which is derived by tradi-
tion from the songs of camel drivers is distin-
guished by quick turns of phrase with no
slower elaboration. The Thumri is a very light
form which was inspired by the Radha Krishna
theme. It was patronised by Wajid Ali Shah,
the last Nawab of Oudh before it was annexed
by the British. The Ghazal, a Persian lyrical
form, has been completely naturalised in In-
dia. It is perhaps the most popular Hindustani
style today.
In North Indian music there are some
purely instrumental compositions,
gat
and
dhun,
which are usually played on plucked
string instruments. The emphasis is on the im-
provisation with the instrumentalist and the
drummer alternating till the climax is reached.
The composed piece is generally short. All the
technical resources of the instruments are used
to build up the fabric of the
gat
which is first
played in a slow tempo and then builds up to
a climax in the fast tempo. Other instrumental
forms are the
thumri,
which is basically an in-
strumental rendering for a vocal
thumri
and
dhun
which is based on a folk tune and does
not follow a conventional Raga.
Muslim and Hindu devotional group sing-
ing has resulted in the evolution of the Abhang
(in Maharashtra), the Kirtan (in Bengal and
Orissa) and the Bhajan which has a greater
regional spread and is sung in both northern
and southern India. Saintly people of all
classes,
from Meera who was a princess of Rajasthan,
to Kabir who was a weaver of Banaras' have
enriched the legacy of this form.
The Mughal emperors were, with the ex-
ception of Aurangzeb, patrons of music. Babar,
Humayun, Akbar, Jahangir and Shah Jahan
had an ear for music and patronised musi-
cians. The legendary Tansen was a member of
Akbar's court. His original name was Ramtanu
Pande and he was born in 1506 in Gwalior.
His natural talent for singing was developed
by Swami Haridas of Brindavan who gave
him a sound training in the finer points of
music. He was a close friend of Sur Das and,
like many of his contemporaries, received
much of his musical education at Gwalior,