122 / 154
ENTSOG TYNDP 2017 Public consultation questionnaire
Q28:
TYNDP 2017 takes a qualitative approach to the
embedded diversification of the LNG supply, based on
expert views provided by GLE (Gas LNG Europe). Do
you welcome this qualitative approach supported by
expert views?
Q29:
Some potential supply sources are not included
in the TYNDP assessment as they are considered as
having a high level of uncertainty. They are
nevertheless investigated in the supply chapter (such
as gas from Turkmenistan, Iran, Egypt and Israel). Do
you see benefits in covering those uncertain sources
in the supply chapter?
Yes
Yes,
Please specify:
Since diversification of supply sources should be
considered as one of main drivers for infrastructure
development all possible sources should be
thoroughly analysed for their potential. In particular
given that Iran was considered one of the sources
that remains uncertain.
PAGE 11: Infrastructure
Q30:
Would you like to provide input to the
Infrastructure section?
Yes
PAGE 12: Infrastructure
Q31:
In addition to the FID status (for projects having
taken their final investment decision) TYNDP 2017
defines an advanced project status, to distinguish
between advanced and less-advanced non-FID
projects. TYNDP 2017 assessment subsequently
focuses on what the FID and advanced projects
achieve. Do you consider this provides a realistic view
on infrastructure development?
No,
If no, please specify why:
Current data lead to distorted view – they don’t take
into account how project will influence competition
on both EU and regional gas markets as well as
thesecurity of gas supply. Some projects need to be
considered as providing more added value for
integration of the Internal Gas Market than the
others. In particular, diversification infrastructure
such as connection between Norwegian Continental
Shel and Poland or PL-UA connection should be
considered as crucial as these projects enhance
diversification of supply sources. According to the
European Energy Security Strategy, CEE region is
still over 60% dependent on supplies from single
source. Further integration requires new
infrastructure projects which will bring diversification
for CEE markets. Otherwise, instead of boosting
competition, further integration will jeopardize
competition in the European market and other
achievement of the Energy Union.
Q32:
TYNDP 2017 provides the overall investment
costs for projects of a given status. Do you find this
information valuable?
Yes