1063 / 1195
OFFICIAL METHODS
SM
EXPERT REVIEW PANEL
OMAMAN-07 :EVALUATION OF THE ANSR® FOR SALMONELLA ASSAY FOR IDENTIFICATION OF
SALMONELLA
SPP. FROM COLONY
PICKS FROM SELECTIVE/DIFFERENTIAL AGAR MEDIA: COLLABORATIVE STUDY
TECHNICAL EVALUATION CRITERIA:
1.
Is the test kit method scientifically and technically sound?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
2.
Have sufficient controls been used, including those required to calculate the rate of false‐positive and false‐negative results
where appropriate?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
3. Is sufficient information included for system suitability determination and product performance or acceptance testing?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
no
3.
Are the conclusions statements valid based upon data presented?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
no
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
4.
Do you agree that the evidence or data from this and previous studies support the proposed applicability statement?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
no
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
AOAC Research Institute - Expert Review Panel Use Only
Page
1
of
8
Expert Reviewers: 1)Donna Douey, 2)Tom Hammack, 3)Maria Fernandez, 4) Yvonne Salfinger, 5)Tony Hitchins, 6)Michael Brodsky