1068 / 1195
OFFICIAL METHODS
SM
EXPERT REVIEW PANEL
OMAMAN-07 :EVALUATION OF THE ANSR® FOR SALMONELLA ASSAY FOR IDENTIFICATION OF
SALMONELLA
SPP. FROM COLONY
PICKS FROM SELECTIVE/DIFFERENTIAL AGAR MEDIA: COLLABORATIVE STUDY
EDITORIAL EVALUATION CRITERIA
1.
Is the Validation Study Manuscript in a format acceptable to AOAC?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
?
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
2.
Is the method described in sufficient detail so that it is relatively easy to understand, including equations and procedures for
calculation of results (are all terms explained)?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
3.
Are the figures and tables sufficiently explanatory without the need to refer to the text?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
no
4.
Are all the figures and tables pertinent?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
yes
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
yes
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
yes
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
no
5.
Could some be omitted and covered by a simple statement?
1.
Expert Reviewer 1
yes
2.
Expert Reviewer 2
no
3.
Expert Reviewer 3
no
4.
Expert Reviewer 4
no
5.
Expert Reviewer 5
yes
6.
Expert Reviewer 6
yes
AOAC Research Institute - Expert Review Panel Use Only
Page
6
of
8
Expert Reviewers: 1)Donna Douey, 2)Tom Hammack, 3)Maria Fernandez, 4) Yvonne Salfinger, 5)Tony Hitchins, 6)Michael Brodsky