529 / 1195
Reviewer #
14.
Are there any concerns regarding the data manipulation, data tables or statistical
analyses
(if necessary, refer to the review from the Statistics Advisor)
?
1
No
2
No
3
No
4
Please refer to the review from the Statistics Advisor.
5
no
6
No comments
7
No
Reviewer #
15. Comments:
1
Good manuscript
2
None
3
For all document: is it queso fresco or soft Mexican cheese? Page 4 line 28: Oxford Agar (OXA) On
page 5 line 33 item B Apparatus and Reagents, mention B.(a); B(b.)……….. The same comment for the
other points. On page 9 line 34: inter- laboratory has to be changed to collaborative study
4
No additional comments.
5
6
Yes
7
EDITORIAL EVALUATION CRITERIA
Reviewer #
1.
Is the Validation Study Manuscript in a format acceptable to AOAC?
1
Yes
2
Yes
3
Yes
4
Yes
5
Yes
6
Yes
7
Reviewer #
2.
Is the method described in sufficient detail so that it is relatively easy to
understand, including equations and procedures for calculation of results (are all
terms explained)?
1
Yes
2
Yes
3
Yes
4
Yes
5
Yes
6
Yes
7
Reviewer #
3.
Are the figures and tables sufficiently explanatory without the need to refer to the
5
21 June 2013