760 / 1195
EDITORIAL EVALUATION CRITERIA
Reviewer #
1.
Is the Validation Study Manuscript in a format acceptable to AOAC?
1
Yes
2
Yes
3
4
Yes
5
Yes
6
Yes
7
Reviewer #
2.
Is the method described in sufficient detail so that it is relatively easy to understand,
including equations and procedures for calculation of results (are all terms explained)?
1
Yes
2
Yes
3
4
Yes
5
Yes
6
Yes
7
Reviewer #
3.
Are the figures and tables sufficiently explanatory without the need to refer to the text?
1
Yes
2
Yes
3
4
Yes
5
Yes
6
Yes
7
Reviewer #
4.
Are all the figures and tables pertinent?
1
Yes
2
No
3
4
Yes
5
Yes
6
Yes
7
Reviewer #
5.
Could some be omitted and covered by a simple statement?
1
No
2
Yes
3
4
No
6
21 June 2013