Reviewer Name:
Yang Zhou
Email:
yangzhou@eurofinsus.comOrganization:
Eurofins
General Information
Method Reviewed:
LUT‐01
Method Title:
QUANTITATIVE MEASURMENT OF BETA‐CRYPTOXANTHIN IN PAPRIKA OLEORESIN,
EXTRACT AND DIETARY SUPPLEMENTS (BEADLETS)
Applicable SMPR
2016.004
Summary of Method:
Based on the sample matrix (paprika oleoresin, extract, or dietary supplement) and
I. Summary
detection instrumentation (HPLC or UV), samples are extracted with corresponding
extraction solvent. Saponification is performed for paprika oleoresin. The extraction
solvent is then quantified by HPLC or UV reading.
1. Does the Applicability of the
Method Support the Applicability
of the SMPR? If not, please explain
No. This method didn't demonstrate its capability to separate and quantify beta‐
cryptoxanthin isomers, lutein and zeaxanthin.
II. Review of the Method Only
what is missing.
2. Does the analytical technique(s)
used in the method meet the
SMPR? If not, please specify how it
differs from what is stated in the
SMPR.
Yes
3. Are the definitions specified in
the SMPR used and applied
appropriatly in the method? If no,
please indicate how the terms are
used.
No. In this method, it specified dietary supplements in beadlets form.
4. Does the method, as written,
contain all appropriate precautions
and warnings related to the
No. Suggested wording: In this method, various organic solvents (hexanes,
chloroform, etc.,) along with several other hazardous chemicals are used and special
care should be taken when handling or disposing of these chemicals. Wear gloves,
method's regaents, components,
instrumentation, or method steps
that may be hazardous? If no,
please suggest wording or
option(s).
safety glasses and use in a fume hood. Follow all laboratory safety precautions. Refer
to Safety Data Sheets (SDS) for any questions relating to any chemicals in use.
1. Are the definitions specified in
No. Reproducibility was replaced by word "ruggedness", which is a completely
III. Review of Information in Support of the Method
the SMPR used and applied
appropriately in the supporting
documentation (manuscripts,
method studies, etc…)? If not,
please explain the differences and
if the method is impacted by the
difference.
different property of a method.