Name that Section: Frequently Used Education Code and Title 5 Sections for Community College Districts
©2018 (c) Liebert Cassidy Whitmore
30
iii. Violations Are a Frequent Source of Liability
The hiring of “short-term employees” is one of the most hotly contested and difficult issues
facing community college districts. Indeed, violations of this provision are a frequent source of
liability and have resulted in millions of dollars in settlements. The most frequently violated
requirement—and most often resisted—is that the service, once completed,
will not be extended
or needed on a continuing basis.
This means, for example, that districts cannot continually hire
seasonal financial aid clerks, admissions, clerks, bookstore clerks, and instructional aides. In
other words, instead of seasonal temporary employment, these employees must be given
permanent part-time employee status.
LCW Practice Advisor
In the short run, it may be seem less costly to districts
to continue with their practices of seasonal temporary
employment. But following the law and complying with
the Education Code will in the long run save districts
from the possibility of facing even more costly liability.
4. S
UBSTITUTES
(N
ON
-M
ERIT
S
YSTEMS
)
67
A “substitute” employee is one who is hired to replace a classified employee temporarily absent
from duty. To be excluded from classification, a substitute employee must be employed and
paid for less than 75% of the college year. Seventy-five percent of a college year for substitutes
also means 195 working days, including holidays, sick leave, vacation, and other leaves of
absence, irrespective of the number of hours worked per day. The 195 days must be all in the
same school year.
68
Non-working Saturdays and Sundays are not counted in determining
whether employees of a school district should be regarded as classified employees.
69
If the district is in the process of trying to fill a permanent position, the governing board can fill
the vacancy with substitute employees on a temporary basis, provided that the employment does
not exceed 60 days, unless a provision in a Collective Bargaining Agreement provides otherwise.
Note:
A substitute employee that is employed for more than 195 working days is presumed to
become a probationary employee.
70
LCW Practice Advisor
In addition to consulting the Education Code, you
should always check the appropriate collective
bargaining agreement provisions to determine if there
are any additional hiring rules that are applicable.
Case Study on Substitute Employees:
California School Employees Assn. v. Governing Bd. Of the South Orange
Community College District
71
The District hired Samuel Hamblen as a substitute warehouse worker during the
1997-1998 college year. During that time, Hamblen substituted for several
classified employees 222 days of the college year. Alfredo Osuna worked as a
substitute custodian 229 days during the 1998-1999 college year. From 1996