113 / 154
ENTSOG TYNDP 2017 Public consultation questionnaire
Q33:
TYNDP 2017 is accompanied with a new TYNDP
projects map (Annex B). Do you find this information
valuable?
Q34:
In this edition, project promoters reported if their
project were part of the national plan. Do you find this
information valuable?
Yes
Yes
Q35:
Is there further information on projects that you would like to see reflected in TYNDP?
Transparency on costs per project is required, including CAPEX and OPEX costs (network losses / fuel gas).
Pro & cons by project promoters should be much more carefully completed, and should be object to a consultation of
all relevant stakeholders.
More information on the grouping of projects, on competing projects, should also be included.
Gas and power projects should be easily comparable, with the same unities, and an order of magnitude of the
impact on the OPEX costs should also be provided. Indeed, losses incurred when transferring massive quantities of
North Sea wind power to Italian demand will be very different, seen from a cross-commodity perspective, if it's
realised by power infrastructure than with gas infrastructure (e.g. by reducing gas fired plants output in Germany and
using them more in Italy). Of course, lots of assumptions are required to make such a computation, and current
power network losses are rather limited, but scenarios implying huge transfers of renewable power across Europe
could considerably increase power network losses.
Q36: The Barriers to Investment chapter analyses the
obstacles to future investment in gas infrastructure as
perceived by project promoters. Do you consider all
potential barriers are covered?
Q37:
Annex A provides project-level information,
through project fiches and overview tables (including
on perceived barriers to investment). Do you find the
Annex A format adequate?
Respondent skipped this
question
No,
If no, how can we further improve?
Project level information should not be simply an
annex, but should be subject to stakeholders
consultation process. Stakeholders can challenge
some characteristics of the projects, in order to
improve the quality of the data included in the
TYNDP. It should be completed with cost
information.
PAGE 13: Assessment, Energy Transition and Gas Quality Outlook
Q38:
Would you like to provide input to the
Assessment section?
Yes
PAGE 14: Assessment, Energy Transition and Gas Quality Outlook