109 / 154
ENTSOG TYNDP 2017 Public consultation questionnaire
Q9:
What are the TYNDP elements most valuable for
your activity?
Demand scenarios, Supply potentials,
Information on projects, Barriers to investment,
Identification of the infrastructure needs ,
Assessment of TYNDP projects and TYNDP
modelling results provided in Annex E
,
Information on the TYNDP modelling (Annex F) ,
Other (please specify below)
TYNDP is a very important exercise for three
reasons : - it allows to identify security of supply or
excessive dependency on a single supplier at EU
level, and therefore allows to trigger useful
investment required to produce an integrated gas
energy market; - on the other hand, it can give
justification to investment not strictly needed. If
these investments are socialized, they will increase
the cost of gas, and will negatively impact market
integration by rising cross-border tariffs; - all its
hypothesis are a widely used public reference, that
impacts gas advocacy.
PAGE 5: General feedback
Q10:
Would you like to provide input to the General
Feedback section?
Yes
PAGE 6: General feedback
Q11:
Is TYNDP 2017 easy to read and navigate
through?
difficult*,
* If difficult, please specify below:
ENTSOG has been extremely didactic and produced
a very high quality document whenever gas balance
or pure security of supply issues are concerned. This
is a real achievement given the very wide scope of
the exercise. On the other hand, ENTSOG has
included more market related indicators. Hypothesis
used to derive prices are not clear enough, and
understanding the signification of some indicators is
also difficult because they mix a physical and
commercial dimension.
Q12:
Are the maps, graphs and tables easy to
understand?
difficult*,
* If difficult, please specify below:
Same issue as previous question
Q13:
ENTSOG organised a workshop in July 2016 to
inform stakeholders on the input data to TYNDP and
subsequently published this data on its website:
demand, supply, gas quality, information on projects.
Has this been useful to you?
Yes