74 / 1195
N/A
Reviewer 9 (McMahon):
N/A
III.
RECOMMENDATION:
a.
Do you recommend that the ERP adopt this method as an AOAC
Official Methods of
Analysis (First Action status)
?
Reviewer 1 (Achen):
Yes.
Reviewer 2 (Douey):
If concerns, suggestions above are addressed, then yes, I would recommend the ERP adopt
this method as an AOAC Official Method of Analysis (First Action Status).
Reviewer 3 (Hitchins):
Yes, I recommend First Action Status.
Reviewer 4 (Brodsky):
Yes.
Reviewer 5 (Hammack):
Yes, but not unless the OMA method includes the corrections that I have indicated above.
In short, sections D and G should be updated, as I indicated above, and there should be a
reference section in the method.
Reviewer 6 (Hayes):
N/A
Reviewer 7 (Fernandez):
Yes
Reviewer 8 (Chen):
Yes
Reviewer 9 (McMahon):
Yes
IV.
AFTER FIRST ACTION STATUS:
a.
Is there any additional information that the ERP should consider in order to recommend
the method for Final Action status?
Reviewer 1 (Achen):
Not applicable.